• Home
  • Get A Quote
  • Customer Service
  • Refer a Friend
  • About Us
  • Location Map
  • Employee Directory
  • Privacy Policy
  • Contact Us
 
CALL US AT 352.332.0180
Home
  • Home
  • Get A Quote
  • Customer Service
  • What We Offer
    • Auto Insurance
    • Business Insurance
    • Commercial Auto Insurance
    • Contractors Insurance
    • Home Insurance
    • Renters Insurance
    • Boat | Motorcycle | RV
  • Blog
  • Resources
    • Secure File Area
    • Refer a Friend
    • Important Links
    • Insurance Glossary
  • About Us
    • About Us
    • Location Map
    • Privacy Policy
  • Contact
    • Contact Us
    • Join Our Newsletter
Auto Insurance PERSONAL AUTO
Auto Insurance COMMERCIAL AUTO
Homeowners Insurance HOME
Business Insurance BUSINESS
Toy Insurance TOYS
Contractors Insurance CONTRACTORS
Home > Blog > Separate Households: Whose Insurance Covers the Kids' Accidents?
FRIDAY, MARCH 29, 2019

Separate Households: Whose Insurance Covers the Kids' Accidents?

Separate Households: Whose Insurance Covers the Kids' Accidents?

Michael and Maureen divorced after 18 years of marriage and agreed to joint custody of their three children. Their 11 year-old son Mikey is riding his bike one afternoon with some friends and not paying full attention to the road in front of him. A five year-old child chasing a ball runs into the road and Mikey strikes her with his bike, causing her to fall and break her arm. The child's furious parents sue both Michael and Maureen for compensation for her injuries and trauma.

Not long after, their 16 year-old son Mark gets his drivers license. One evening while driving home, he swerves to avoid a deer in the road, loses control, and plows into two parked cars. Both cars are relatively new; the repair bills come to thousands of dollars.

Because Michael and Maureen now have separate households, they each have their own auto and homeowner's insurance policies. Are both parents responsible for the children's actions? Is only the parent who had custody at the time of the accident responsible? And whose insurance pays for the damages? Will either policy pay? With the increasing prevalence of two-household families and blended families, the question of which parent (and, therefore, which insurance policy) is responsible for a child's actions has become more common. The answer is not always clear.

A standard homeowner's policy covers the people named on it (the named insureds); household residents who are either relatives of the named insureds or under age 21 and in the care of a named insured or relative; and full-time college students who are either relatives of the named insureds and under age 24 or others in the care of a household resident and under age 21. A standard auto policy covers the named insureds and "family members" (residents of the household related to the named insureds by blood, marriage, or adoption, including ward or foster children.) Michael and Maureen have joint custody of their children. In which parent's household are the children residents?

State laws and courts have answered this question in a variety of ways. For example, states such as New York have established "dual residency"; that is, a person can be a legal resident of multiple households at the same time. However, other states such as Montana have laws prohibiting dual residency. Some courts start with the custody awarded in the divorce decree but also consider how the parents are actually handling custody. A New Jersey court found that a child had dual residency, despite the mother having legal custody, because both parents had actual custody at different times. The judge ruled that both parents' homeowner's policies applied to the child.

Other states have ruled that no one factor determines residency; a court must look at multiple factors. A Georgia court devised an approach that measures custody time and focuses on whether there is in fact more than one household. New Jersey courts look at both measurable factors and qualitative factors, such as whether people in the household function together as family members.

If Michael and Maureen live in a dual residency state, both their homeowner's and auto policies may cover the accidents their children have. Policy terms explain how they share loss payments for these incidents. In other states, the solution may be more complicated. A court may weigh several factors and assign residency to only one of the households, requiring one parent's insurance to pay for the loss. Since the outcome in these situations is uncertain, the best thing for divorced parents to do is to make sure they have plenty of insurance provided by financially strong companies.

Thank you for visiting the Partners Insurance Agency blog. We hope you found our content helpful and informative.

Posted 3:00 PM

Tags: insurance, separate households
Share |


No Comments


Post a Comment
Required
Required (Not Displayed)
Required


All comments are moderated and stripped of HTML.

NOTICE: This blog and website are made available by the publisher for educational and informational purposes only. It is not be used as a substitute for competent insurance, legal, or tax advice from a licensed professional in your state. By using this blog site you understand that there is no broker client relationship between you and the blog and website publisher.
Blog Archive
  • 2021
  • 2020
  • 2019
  • 2018
  • 2017
  • 2016

  • insurance(99)
  • homeowners insurance(44)
  • auto insurance(40)
  • business insurance(29)
  • home insurance(11)
  • boat insurance(8)
  • workers compensation(8)
  • insurance claims(8)
  • liability insurance(7)
  • flood insurance(6)
  • liability(5)
  • additional insured(5)
  • commercial liability insurance(4)
  • d&o insurance(4)
  • umbrella insurance(4)
  • hurricane preparedness(4)
  • commercial auto insurance(4)
  • renters insurance(4)
  • insurance discounts(4)
  • teen drivers(3)
  • vacation rental insurance(3)
  • business owners policy(3)
  • tria(3)
  • small business insurance(3)
  • insurance coverage(3)
  • water damage(3)
  • summer safety(3)
  • workplace safety(3)
  • commercial insurance(3)
  • commerical insurance(3)
  • covid-19(3)
  • uber(2)
  • non-owned auto insurance(2)
  • drunk driving(2)
  • employee fraud(2)
  • terrorism risk insurance(2)
  • business owners insurance(2)
  • insurance liability(2)
  • freezing pipes(2)
  • halloween safety(2)
  • auto accident scams(2)
  • holiday safety(2)
  • natural disasters(2)
  • contractors(2)
  • moving(2)
  • dog liability insurance(2)
  • forced-placed insurance(2)
  • claims process(2)
  • buisiness insurance(2)
  • general liability(2)

View Mobile Version
Facebook
Twitter
LinkedIn
Carriers
logo, company name
text, logo
Carriers
logo
icon
logo, company name
PIA

Resources

Home About Us Get a Quote Customer Service Contact Us
a drawing of a face

Contact Us

icon
  • 4040 W Newberry Road Suite 950
  • Gainesville, FL 32607
  • Office: 352.332.0180
  • Fax: 352.378.5820
© Copyright. All rights reserved.
Powered by Insurance Website Builder